54-40 or Fight Quilt Block

From our Free Quilt Block Pattern Library

This post contains affiliate links for which I receive compensation.

Skill Level: Confident Beginner

The 54-40 or Fight quilt block is made from two basic units: four patches (in two color combinations) and a triangle in a square unit.

This three fabric block is based on a 3x3 grid.

On this page you'll find complete directions to make a 9" version of this block, along with links to free downloads for the paper pieced units.

For inspiration, several variations of this design are illustrated.

Because all quilters sometimes make blocks that don't quite work—I share an 'oops!'—a quick lesson in color value to help you avoid a common mistake and make more spectacular blocks!

And finally, see this block paired as an alternate block in our short video 'Quilt Layouts 101'.

General Instructions

You'll need three fabrics to construct this 9" 54-40 or Fight quilt block—a background fabric, a two others of either medium or dark value.

It's important that there is enough contrast between the star points and the background fabric.

If there isn't, the star points will get lost in the design.

Our background fabric is yellow, Fabric A is the print, Fabric B is orange.

Step 1: Download paper pieced patterns, templates

The Triangle in a Square (TiaS) units are paper pieced for accuracy. Click on each of the links below. This takes you to the PDF page where you can print.

In order to print blocks at the correct size, under 'Page Sizing and Handling' in the Adobe print menu, set 'Custom Scale' to 100%. Click here to see what it looks like on the Print Menu page.

Click here for more information on downloading patterns from this website.

Read my review of 6 paper piecing papers available on the market

Not sure which paper to use?

Check out my review of several of the most popular brands available to us quilters on the market.

Which one will you choose?

2021 Showcase Fabrics ~ Get ready to drool!

Click any of the images below to see the full collection, individual fabrics and find pricing/ordering information.

Check out ALL the current Fabric lines showcased on this site in one place.

Step 2: Cut the 54-40 or Fight patches

Sample Size: 9" finished / 9½" unfinished

Grid: 9x9

Attribution: Ruth Finley

AKA: Grandma's Star (Clara Stone), The Railroad Quilt (Rural New Yorker)

Design Type: Even 9-patch, Star

The strips include a bit of extra length so that you have room to square up the ends if needed.

Corner four patch unit

For the corner four patches, cut:

  • Background: One 2" x 17" strip
  • Fabric A: One 2" x 17" strip
Center four patch unit

For the center four patch, cut:**

  • Background: One 2" x 4-1/2" strip
  • Fabric B: One 2" x 4-1/2"strip

**If you have come to this page from our video "Quilt Layouts: Part I", replace this center four patch with a solid 3-1/2" square from a fourth fabric of light/medium value.

Triangle in a square unit

For the TiaS, cut from the:

  • Background: Four Template A
  • Fabric B: Four 3" x 4" rectangles.

Layer these rectangles, two pairs of right sides together.

Warning: If you lay all the rectangles either all right side up or all right side down, you will end up with either 8 left or 8 right triangle points—not fun!!

Lay Template B on top aligning all the edges. With your rotary cutter and ruler cut through the template and all four layers along the diagonal line.

Separate these triangles into two piles, four of the left triangle patch and four of the right triangle patch.

Step 3: Assemble the patches for a 54-40 or Fight

Corner Four Patches

Make 4

Stitch the two 2"x17" strips together into a strip set. After stitching, it measures 3-1/2"x17".

Press the unit flat to set the seam. Then press the unit open with the seam allowances towards the dark. Press in this manner every time you are instructed to 'press' for flatter, more accurate quilt blocks.

Cut and sew the patches for the corner four patch units

Make eight 2" wide subcuts.

Sew them into four four patches that measure 3-1/2" x 3-1/2". Press and set aside.

The finished corner four patch units

Center Four Patch

Make 1

Stitch the 2" x 4-1/2" rectangles together into a strip set that measure 3-1/2" x 4-1/2". Press.

Subcut into two 2" wide units.

Cut and sew the center four patch unit

Sew them into a four patch unit that measures 3-1/2" x 3-1/2". Press and set aside.

Triangle in a Square (TiaS)

Make 4

Take the patterns you printed in Step 1 and rough cut just outside the dotted lines of the block patterns. There's no reason to be exact as we'll trim them later.

Do cut the templates out on the lines as it will assist in placing them on your fabric and minimizing waste.

For a lesson on making this unit, visit our Triangle in a Square tutorial.

Trim to Size

Once all the units are completely stitched, I line them all up at the same time on the cutting mat.

Align the 1/4" line of the ruler with the outside sewing line (the solid line) and trim each block individually. Having the blocks all lined up saves time. You don't need to move the ruler so much for each cut.

Use a small mat for this trimming, and you can turn the mat instead of each individual block—saving even MORE time.

Align your ruler's 1/4inch line with the solid outside line and trim

Repeat for each side of every TiaS unit and you'll end up with these perfect little units that measure 3-1/2" x 3-1/2".

Finished triangle in a square units

Step 4: Assemble your 54-40 or Fight quilt block

Layout your units to create the 54-40 or Fight design—paying special attention to the orientation of the four patches. (Substitute that 3-1/2" for the center four patch if needed.)

54-40 or Fight quilt block units are laid out in rows

Sew each row together. Press with the seam allowances in the direction of the arrows, towards the four patch units.

Pin the top row to the middle row. Stitch. Press flat to set the seams, then again with the SA towards the center row. Repeat for the bottom row.

Congratulations! You have made 54-40 or Fight quilt block that measures 9-1/2" square from edge to edge.

Your 54-40 or Fight quilt block is finishedThis 54-40 or Fight is ready for a quilt

Variations on a 54-40 or Fight Quilt Block

Quilters love to play with their blocks. There are several blocks based on the 54-40 or Fight quilt block that merely change the number of fabrics used or the position of those fabrics.

Grandma's Star quilt block

This two-color version is most commonly known as Grandma's Star. Other names include Nine Patch Star Quilt and Railroad Quilt.

The four patch units form chains on the diagonal that run in one direction.

Garden Patch quilt block

Another two color variation. This time the four patches form chains that cross the block. It is called Garden Patch or Texas or An Old Fashioned Pinwheel.

Bird of Paradise quilt block

This 'Bird of Paradise' version requires three fabrics. The crossing chains formed by the four patches are almost disguised by the color placement.

Oops! A Lesson in Color Value

The 54-40 or Fight quilt block requires three fabrics.

In a successful block there is enough difference in the values of the fabrics so that both the four patches and the star points show.

To the right is the first sample I made for this block. All beautiful hand dyed fabrics, that when laid out next to each other looked perfect.

But as you can see, once it was assembled the star points pretty much disappeared into the 4-patches.

This does happen every now and again. Something looks great as individual fabrics, but then just doesn't work when the patches are stitched together. No quilter is immune.

The lessons learned:

  • To see all the elements of the design, there needs to be enough contrast between them, and...
  • Make a sample block before committing to your final fabric selection.

Use as an alternate block

In our short video, "Quilt Layouts 101", you can watch how we've paired this block with a Mrs. Brown's Choice quilt block to come up with a dazzling quilt design.

Pour yourself a glass of liquid refreshment (mine's a latte!) and enjoy!

Share your work to inspire other Quilters!

If you use our tutorials to make your blocks and quilts, there are some easy ways to share your creations so other quilters (including me!) can enjoy the fruits of your labor:

  • On Instagram please tag your blocks and quilts with the hashtag #GenerationsQuiltPatterns.
  • Visit our Show n'Tell page on the website. Click here to share photos and tell your own story, just start typing at 'The name of your quilt is...'. If you'd prefer to submit more photos than the form allows, simply email them to me at julie@generations-quilt-patterns.com.

I love seeing your work!

Our readers do, too!

For even more blocks to make...

Click here to learn about my favorite quilt book resources that inspire my patchwork designs.

For you, are quilt block patterns like potato chips...

...you can't have just one?!!

Check the amazing resources I rely on for the majority of the quilt block designs you see on this website. 

To see if they're worthy of spot in YOUR quilting library, read about them HERE.

NOTE: All the attribution and alternate names shared in the Free Quilt Block Patterns Library came from these four resources.

This article was printed from Generations-Quilt-Patterns.com

Print Article

Follow Us